When seeing doesn’t mean recognizing: understanding visual agnosia

I guess you’ve heard of the most famous book written by the neurologist Oliver Sacks: The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat.
But do you know which neurological disorder lies behind it?

The story is about a musician (Doctor P) who could not recognize his students by their faces, but could recognize them by their voices.
He could pick out very small details in pictures but failed to perceive the whole scene.
He could not recognize family members unless they had a striking detail (a large mustache, a peculiar nose).
He could identify a rose by its smell, but not by its appearance.
He could describe details of a landscape but could not see it as a whole (a desert, a lake, mountains) and so on.

And yet, all his other neurological functions were intact. He did not have dementia, he could play music, hold a conversation, and move normally.

So, what was happening? The answer is agnosia.

More in detail, Doctor P had visual agnosia which is defined as the inability to recognize objects by sight as well as a subtype called prosopagnosia, the inability to recognize faces.

To picture it, imagine showing someone a cup as asking: what is this object?
Instead of naming it, they describe: “It’s an object with a hole, made of ceramic, red with white spots, rough texture…” but never say cup or “used for drinking tea or coffee.”
That’s visual agnosia.
Normally, when we see an object, we don’t just register its shape or color—we instantly connect it to its meaning and use. Doctor P’s vision itself was intact, but the pathway linking perception to recognition was broken.

Agnosia comes in many forms—visual, auditory, tactile, and others—each with its subtypes. Causes range from strokes, tumors, infections, dementia or developmental disorders.
Unfortunately there is no direct cure and trying to rebuild the lost pathways rarely works. What seems to help is occupational therapy, which focuses on compensating with intact senses (a super-interesting example of the brain’s ability to reorganize itself). In fact, usually a person with visual agnosia can still recognize objects by touch, smell, or sound.

The bright side is that agnosia remains a rare neurological disorder.

References:

If you want to share this post: